As the dust settles from the 2024 presidential election, the political landscape reveals a clear victory for Donald Trump. Securing both the electoral college and the popular vote, Trump has cemented a historic return to the White House. Meanwhile, Vice President Kamala Harris and the Democratic Party face not only defeat but the pressing need to confront deep-rooted strategic failures that resonate beyond this election cycle.
The Popular Vote Shift and Democratic Disengagement
A striking factor in Harris’s defeat is the drastic drop in Democratic support compared to 2020. While Biden secured 81 million votes four years ago, Harris garnered only 69.1 million, a 12-million-vote decrease. While Trump’s vote count remained consistent with 2020 numbers, it appears that millions of traditional Democratic voters chose to stay home. This stark shift highlights a growing disengagement among voters who felt the party offered little in the way of real solutions.
Many Democrats stayed home, discouraged by the continuity of Biden’s policies and frustrated by a Democratic leadership that failed to prioritize the economic issues affecting American households. This disengagement reveals a broader dissatisfaction with the direction of the Democratic Party and its perceived lack of responsiveness to working-class struggles.
Economic Discontent and the Lasting Impact of the 2008 Crisis
Economic hardship continues to drive American politics, a reality that has deepened since the 2008 financial crisis. While Biden’s administration focused on recovery efforts post-COVID, inflation surged, leaving millions of Americans with declining real income. The Biden years saw an official price increase of around 24%, but voters felt a more severe pinch. Rising costs for mortgages, credit, and everyday goods eroded disposable income, amplifying discontent among households already bearing the brunt of economic inequality.
These economic pressures gave Trump an edge as he capitalized on the sentiment that the political elite, both Democratic and Republican, had failed to address the lopsided economy that continues to benefit the top 1%. Trump’s platform, promising tax relief and tariffs, resonated with working-class Americans who felt left behind by the current administration’s policies.
Harris’s Strategic Missteps
Harris’s failure to differentiate herself from Biden’s policies cost her significantly. By aligning with Biden’s stance on both economic and foreign policy issues, she missed an opportunity to present a fresh, responsive vision that might have reinvigorated the Democratic base. Like Hubert Humphrey in 1968, who could not break with Lyndon Johnson’s policies on Vietnam, Harris’s steadfast alignment with Biden’s agenda only served to remind voters of the administration’s shortcomings, particularly on economic issues.
Overreliance on Identity Politics
The Democratic strategy, heavily rooted in identity politics, has lost its appeal. While issues of gender, race, and orientation remain important, they no longer carry the weight they once did, especially when economic issues are at the forefront. The Democrats’ emphasis on identity politics appeared out of touch to a public increasingly concerned with material struggles. Harris’s campaign relied on issues that resonated less with a diverse working-class electorate facing rising costs and economic insecurity.
Trump’s Appeal to the ‘Bros Vote’ and Working-Class Men
Trump’s approach captured the support of working-class men across racial lines, particularly young, non-college-educated men—the “Bros Vote.” These voters have felt the harshest effects of wage stagnation, housing insecurity, and underemployment. By speaking in terms relatable to this demographic and addressing economic issues directly, Trump secured a growing working-class base. His straightforward, sometimes abrasive, communication style struck a chord with those who view political polish as disconnected from their reality.
Missed Economic Opportunities and the Policy Gap
Trump also succeeded by proposing specific economic measures targeted toward working-class Americans, including eliminating taxes on overtime and social security benefits. While Democrats copied some of these measures, Harris and her team ultimately failed to present a compelling economic vision that differentiated them from the Biden administration. In contrast, Trump’s proposals, though occasionally lacking detail, at least acknowledged the economic anxieties that had intensified under Biden.
Consequences and Looking Forward
Looking ahead, Trump’s agenda will likely prioritize executive actions on immigration, tariffs, and deregulation. His commitment to rolling back environmental regulations, increasing oil production, and imposing tariffs reflects a shift toward protectionist and populist policies aimed at reshaping America’s economic landscape. However, his belief in tax cuts as a remedy for economic growth may fall short, as his first term demonstrated limited impact from these measures. The budget deficit and fiscal crises may challenge his administration, likely leading to proposed cuts to social programs—a move that could alienate some of his new working-class base.
For the Democratic Party, Harris’s defeat underscores a need for serious introspection. The 2024 election shows that economic issues must take precedence over identity politics if the party hopes to rebuild its working-class support. Additionally, the Democrats must address their disengaged base, many of whom are looking for authentic leadership that directly addresses the realities of inflation, wage stagnation, and rising costs.
In Summary
The 2024 election results highlight the American electorate’s continued focus on economic challenges. Harris and the Democrats’ failure to respond adequately to these issues, combined with Trump’s strategic appeal to the working class, has shifted the political landscape. Trump’s victory may serve as a reminder that a meaningful connection with voters’ lived experiences, particularly regarding economic issues, remains the most critical determinant of success in American politics. Whether Trump’s policies will ultimately deliver the desired economic relief or disappoint remains to be seen, but for now, his approach has given voice to a disillusioned segment of the American electorate.
OBLONG MEDIA UNLIMITED 
Leave a comment